My Totally Unexplainable Love Affair with Cheesy Holiday Romance Movies

You ever have one of those habits that makes absolutely zero sense on paper, but you stick with it anyway because it just feels… weirdly comforting? That’s me and cheesy holiday romance movies. And trust me, nobody is more confused about this than I am.
I mean, I’m the guy who doesn’t put up a tree. I don’t hang lights. I’m not out here sipping peppermint lattes while wearing an ironic sweater with a confused-looking reindeer on it. Honestly, if you walked into my place in December, you might think I skipped straight to February and decided winter was optional. My version of holiday decorating is maybe lighting a candle that smells vaguely like cinnamon if I’m feeling bold. That’s it.
And romance? Yeah. Not exactly my go-to genre. I can handle it in small doses, preferably tucked inside something else—mystery, noir, ghosts, magic, explosions, you get the idea. The only time I want my heartstrings tugged is if a ghost does it. Literally.
But then December creeps up on me—always earlier than I’m prepared for—and suddenly I’m slipping into this bizarre alternate self. A version of me who loves holiday rom-coms. The cheesier the better. The kind where the leads meet in the world’s smallest town where everyone knows everyone, there’s a bakery that only seems to sell gingerbread, and someone has a tragic backstory involving a snow globe.
And the weirdest part? I watch them secretly.
Like, I’ll curl up on the couch—no tree, no twinkly lights, no Michael Bublé defrosting anywhere—and I’ll put on something with a title like Snowflakes & Second Chances or Mistletoe Mix-Up. And then I’ll just… enjoy it?
What is that about.
Where does this seasonal transformation come from?
Why does my brain flip a switch and go, “Oh yes, I crave wholesome strangers wearing red scarves”?
I have absolutely no explanation.
But I do have favorites.
Oh, do I have favorites.
Let me tell you about the one that started this whole thing: The Knight Before Christmas.
It’s cheesy in a way I genuinely admire. Vanessa Hudgens falls for a medieval knight who time-travels to modern Ohio during Christmas. And I don’t know what happened in the writers’ room for that one, but I hope they all got cookies and a bonus because it hits some strange, delightful part of my brain. Every time he looks confused by, like, an electric kettle, I’m in my happy place. I rewatch it every year. Every. Year. Like some kind of ritual I never signed up for but now can’t skip.
Then there’s The 12 Dates of Christmas, which is basically Groundhog Day but with mistletoe and awkward flirting. I love it. I actually love it. Kate keeps reliving Christmas Eve and has to figure out how to stop sabotaging her own love life. I don’t know if I learn anything from watching it, but I swear it puts me in a better mood than most self-help books.
And speaking of holiday bliss, let’s talk about one of the real gems: Make the Yuletide Gay.
A gay Christmas rom-com where the awkwardness is relatable, the humor is warm without being sticky, and the characters feel like people I might actually want to know. The mom alone? Iconic. It feels like hanging out with a fun friend who refuses to let you disappear into your anti-holiday cave.
What makes these my comfort movies? No clue. Zero. Nada. I’ve tried to analyze it—believe me, I have. I’ve considered everything from seasonal nostalgia to brain chemistry to maybe being possessed by a cheerful December spirit who just wants me to believe in love for two hours at a time. But I’ve got nothing.
And honestly, that’s fine. Some things don’t need a thesis.
Some things are just little joys you stumble into and hold onto.
The best part—and please don’t spread this around—is that I watch these totally in secret. My spouse has no idea. None. If they walked in unexpectedly, I’d probably pretend I was watching a documentary about snowplows or a gritty true crime series about missing fruitcakes. Meanwhile, it’s usually me, under a blanket, watching two dorks fall in love while baking cookies for a festival that only exists in that movie’s universe.
But now you know. And I’m trusting you with this information.
So, hush. Pinky swear. Not a word.
As we roll toward that time of year again, I can already feel the pull. Somewhere deep inside me, a tiny voice is whispering, “You should rewatch A Knight Before Christmas. You know you want to.”
And I do.
I really, really do.
Alright, I’m off to pretend I’m above this kind of thing… while mentally queuing up a list of movies involving strangers bumping into each other in Christmas markets.

Brooklyn nights were never this terrifying. Shadows with teeth prowl the alleys, and a blood-red moon is rising. Armed only with forbidden knowledge, his sister’s faith, and a golem who grows more human by the day, David has to fight back. The Golem’s Guardian – grab your copy HERE.
My Totally Unexplainable Love Affair with Cheesy Holiday Romance Movies Read Post »








